• Online news outlet of Beachwood High School - Follow us on Twitter @bcomberonline - Like our Facebook page "The Beachcomber"

The news site of Beachwood High School.

The Beachcomber

Filed under Editorials, Top Stories

Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

Protesters+gathered+at+Seattle-Tacoma+Airport+and+at+airports+around+the+country+to+protest+Trump%27s+travel+ban+on+Jan.+28.+Photo+by+Dennis+Bratland+via+Wikimedia+Commons.
Protesters gathered at Seattle-Tacoma Airport and at airports around the country to protest Trump's travel ban on Jan. 28. Photo by Dennis Bratland via Wikimedia Commons.

Protesters gathered at Seattle-Tacoma Airport and at airports around the country to protest Trump's travel ban on Jan. 28. Photo by Dennis Bratland via Wikimedia Commons.

Protesters gathered at Seattle-Tacoma Airport and at airports around the country to protest Trump's travel ban on Jan. 28. Photo by Dennis Bratland via Wikimedia Commons.

Advertisement

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






President Trump campaigned on rhetoric that most in our community view as offensive, even  archaic in today’s America.

Equating Mexican immigrants to rapists and criminals, mocking a disabled reporter and building a wall on the border of the US and Mexico were just some of the things that made many Americans think we were listening to a candidate running for president in 1916, not 2016.

Perhaps his most appalling campaign promise was to institute a restriction on Muslim immigration.

In the aftermath of the 2015 San Bernandino shootings, Trump called for a “total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States until our representatives can figure out what is going on.”

He later modified this proposal to what appeared in his Jan. 27 executive order, which included a ban on Syrian refugee resettlement, limited the number of refugees allowed in the US to 50,000 for 2017 and banned all immigration from seven Muslim majority countries, including Iraq, Iran and Syria.

This order prompted the Beachwood City Council to pass a resolution against the order. Superintendent Dr. Bob Hardis sent an e-mail informing the community that even though the order seemed like news irrelevant to our community, it did, in fact, have an effect on some children and families, given that many parents utilize green cards for work, and have family from the countries effected.

The ban was mercifully struck down by US District Judge James Robart of Seattle on Feb 4, and the decision was reaffirmed by a panel of three judges on Feb 9.

After hearing the decision by the panel, our stalwart Commander-in-chief tweeted “SEE YOU IN COURT, THE SECURITY OF OUR NATION IS AT STAKE!” despite the fact that the issue had already been seen by two courts and struck down by each.

Superintendent Dr. Bob Hardis sent an e-mail informing the community that even though the order seemed like news irrelevant to our community, it did, in fact, have an effect on some children and families, given that many parents utilize green cards for work, and have family from the countries affected.”

Now the Trump administration is drafting a new version of the travel ban they hope will survive court scrutiny.

But given the chaos and controversy that the initial order caused, it wasn’t the best idea, for more than a couple of reasons.

We need only look back at our history to understand why this executive order isn’t consistent with America’s core values of inclusion and tolerance.

Trump’s action harkens back to 1882, when Congress passed The Chinese Exclusion Act, which suspended the immigration of Chinese workers for a period of 10 years, and forced every Chinese individual going in and out of the country to carry an identification certificate.

These exclusionary policies are from a period that we look back on with shame, because they violate the principles America was founded on, including the idea that no one should be discriminated against for their religious beliefs.”

Despite assertions that the act would expire in 10 years, it only emboldened Congress to do more, with the passage of the Scott Act, which made it impossible for anyone to re-enter the US after visiting China and ballooned to eventually include Hawaii and the Phillipines. It wasn’t repealed until 1943.

These exclusionary policies are from a period that we look back on with shame, because they violate the principles America was founded on, including the idea that no one should be discriminated against for their religious beliefs.

Trump’s executive order, which singles out Muslim-majority countries and purports to make exemptions for other religious groups from the same countries, clearly violates this principle.

This religious discrimination is one of the main issues that we, as a staff, take with President Trump’s actions. Not only does this have no place in a country that can, for the vast majority, trace its history back to immigrants, but it could usher in an era of extreme discrimination against Muslims, barring a whole group of people from this country simply because of their religion.

There has to be a better way to ensure we are keeping all of our citizens safe from Islamic terror, one that doesn’t take us back to the darker periods in our history.

Print Friendly

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




*

Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

    Sports

    Girls Track Team Wins State Tournament

  • Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

    Sports

    Girls Track Takes Regional Title, Competes at State Tournament This Weekend

  • Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

    Arts & Entertainment

    Impressive Special Effects, Intertwining Plot Strands in ‘Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2’

  • Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

    Editorials

    Advice For Our New Principal, Mr. Srithai

  • Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

    Features

    Assessing the Assessments

  • Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

    Features

    Model U.N. Club Building Momentum

  • Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

    Features

    Coach Iammarino Pins 52nd Year at Beachwood

  • Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

    News

    Srithai Brings Student-Centered Approach

  • Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

    Arts & Entertainment

    ‘Twin Peaks’ Returns After 25 Years

  • Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time

    Features

    Author Marcus Sedgwick Describes Life on the Border

The news site of Beachwood High School.
Dialing Back to a More Shameful Time