After nearly two years of conflict, the recent ceasefire between Israel and Hamas has sparked a mix of relief and cautious optimism for pro-Israel students at BHS.

The agreement includes a halt to hostilities, the release of hostages, and provisions for humanitarian aid, while leaving key political and territorial issues unresolved.

For BHS student and Israeli Culture Club President Meir Bickart, the truce represents both progress and uncertainty.

“It’s a really important step toward peace,” Bickart said. “Most importantly, all of the hostages will be returned, either dead or alive. But Hamas is still in power in Gaza, and true peace or a two-state solution will not come until they’re removed.” 

Within Beachwood’s pro-Israel community, the reaction has been largely positive. 

“After two years, the most important thing was getting the hostages back, and we’re doing that,” Bickart said. 

Still, doubts remain about the durability of the agreement. 

“Israel will not attack unless provoked, and Hamas will most likely provoke,” he said. “I don’t think it’s permanent, but temporary is good enough.”

Bickart said media coverage across the political spectrum has been mostly supportive, although some activists have expressed skepticism now that a ceasefire is in place.

He added that young voters in Israel and abroad can play an important role in promoting peace and understanding. 

“If we can’t talk about things, we can’t understand the other narrative,” Bickart said. “Most Israelis want peace, even if it means giving up a lot for a lasting two-state solution.”